Buying Trading Cards Online: How to Avoid Scams and Fakes

Buying online gives you access to almost any card, but scams and counterfeits are common. These checks protect your money.

Use platforms with buyer protection

Marketplaces like eBay, TCGplayer and Cardmarket offer some form of buyer protection when you pay through their checkout. Paying off-platform removes that protection.

Red flags in listings

• Stock photos instead of photos of the actual card
• Prices far below market for valuable cards
• Vague titles ("rare Charizard holo") without set and number
• New seller accounts selling expensive cards
• "Proxy", "custom", "replica" in the small print
• Requests to pay by gift card, crypto or "friends and family"

Counterfeit cards

Fakes are common for popular Pokémon, Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh! cards. Learn the tells in how to spot fake Pokémon cards. For high-value cards, consider buying graded from major companies.

Fake slabs

Counterfeit graded slabs exist. Always:

• Look up the cert number on the grader's website
• Compare the card, grade and label details with the database (often including images)
• Check the slab for tampering

Resealed and searched packs

• Resealed packs and boxes: check shrink wrap and pack crimps (booster box value)
• Weighed or searched packs: some sellers remove the packs likely to contain hits
• Buy sealed product from reputable stores

Mystery boxes and lots

"Guaranteed hit" mystery boxes and cheap lots often contain fakes or bulk. Treat them as entertainment, not value.

Social media sales

Groups can be fine, but scam risk is higher: use payment methods with protection, check references and be wary of rushed deals.

Before you pay

1. Identify the exact card and condition
2. Check recent sold prices (eBay sold listings)
3. Check the seller's feedback
4. Pay through the platform

Try it on your own cards

Before buying, scan a similar card or the listing photo with Rarefolio to see what the card is and its estimated market value. If a price is far below the estimate, slow down and check the listing carefully.

Frequently asked questions

How do I avoid buying fake Pokémon cards online?

Buy from reputable sellers with clear photos, compare prices with market values, check card details and consider graded cards for expensive purchases.

How can I check if a graded card is real?

Look up the certification number on the grading company's website and compare the details and images.

Is it safe to buy cards on social media?

It can be, but use protected payment methods, check references and avoid rushed deals.

What payment method is safest for buying cards?

Paying through the marketplace's checkout or a payment method with buyer protection is safest.